Harvey J. Graff maintains that we will not be able to see the future possibilities of colleges and universities clearly without a sense of the history of higher education. He argues passionately against reform initiatives which seem to be more firmly rooted in meaningless marketing slogans than concrete policies. His vision of a dynamic and humane university, and the reforms needed to make that vision a reality, are at once common sense and a marked departure from current practices.

Jerry A. Jacobs, Professor Emeritus of Sociology, University of Pennsylvania

Harvey Graff, a seasoned scholar and newly retired academic, has written a book that should be widely read and discussed. It is not a typical screed deploring the fate of the American university. It is an historically grounded sample; he knows that there is no one university formula that fits all. There was no golden age of American university. What is missing are commentators equipped to speak historically about the fate of different institutions. We have precious few of them now, though every publisher seems to have a title that excoriates what is happening to the American university. There are few histories to inform university and college administrators about their duties and obligations, except perhaps raising money. Very few administrators of higher education are in command of their institutions' history. Since the 1960s, if not before, there are predictions of the university's demise. That wrong-headed version is a part of the actual history of students and academics striving to achieve their best with the resources at hand. It is a history fraught with contradictions about which its leaders should be knowledgeable. Read Graff's account of higher education and make up your own mind.

Paul Mattingly, Professor Emeritus of History, New York University

A magnificent achievement that transcends the massive and deeply flawed literature on the contemporary university. Harvey Graff has critically mastered that literature and its mode of production, uncovering its glaring ahistoricism and self serving cant. But far more than that, this book is deeply rooted in the realities of today's universities and colleges. Based on his deep experience, historian's sensibilities and acute analytic skills, Graff provides the first and only analysis that unites the usually disconnected and often disregarded variables that define the higher education crisis, that is, administration, faculty, curriculum, student life (psychological and economic dimensions) and growth, the relationship of universities to their locations and communities and the political and socio- cultural context at all levels. All are integral parts of the “problem.” But Graff goes further and provides solutions, to reintegrate, to overcome the contradictions, to re imagine the University as first and foremost a place that educates.

Daniel Orlovsky, Professor and George Bouhe Research Fellow in Russian Studies, Southern Methodist University

Drawing on his fifty years of direct involvement with large public universities, interdisciplinary social and cultural historian Harvey Graff presents a frank evaluation of these "mismanaged and disorganized” institutions. He provides an extensive review of relevant literature to justify his call for needed changes in higher education today. “Bloated” administrations, rise of temporary lecturer ranks at the expense of those of tenured and tenure-track faculty, mismanagement and abuse of general education requirements, and the often-dubious roles of absentee near-campus landlords are some of the challenges addressed. Graff provides numerous suggestions and ideas to confront such challenges and “reconstruct” these intuitions to meet the needs of the students who attend them, communities that house them, and the society that supports them.

Steve Rissing, Professor Emeritus of Evolutionary Biology, Ohio State University

Deeply researched, relentlessly probing, occasionally frustrating, sometimes annoying, frequently humorous, unfailingly willing to take a stand-even ones you might not expect. It won't answer all your questions, but it will make you question many of your answers.

Robert Bradley, Associate Provost and Professor of Political Science, Florida State University